1 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
2 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|T)\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|T)\) |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y|T)\) Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
3 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
4 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
5 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
6 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
7 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
8 (Mediator) \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
Not Identifiable \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(\sum_{x\in\mathcal{X}}{p(x|T)}\sum_{t\in\mathcal{T}}{p(t)p(Y|X,t)}\) \(\sum_{t\in\mathcal{T}}p(t)p(Y|X,t)\) |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
9 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y|T)\) Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
10 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
11 (Instrument) \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y|T,X)\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(\sum_{x\in\mathcal{X}}{p(x)p(Y|T,x)}\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(p(Y|T,X)\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
12 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(\frac{p(Y)p(X|Y,T)}{\sum_{y\in\mathcal{Y}}{p(y)p(X|y,T)}}\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
13 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
14 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|T)\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|T)\) |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y|T)\) Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
15 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
16 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
17 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
18 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(\frac{p(Y)p(X|Y,T)}{\sum_{y\in\mathcal{Y}}{p(y)p(X|y,T)}}\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X,T)\) |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) \(\frac{p(Y)p(X|Y,T)}{\sum_{y\in\mathcal{Y}}{p(y)p(X|y,T)}}\) |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
19 (Moderator) \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(\sum_{x\in\mathcal{X}}{p(x)p(Y|T,x)}\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(\sum_{x\in\mathcal{X}}{p(x)p(Y|T,x)}\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(\sum_{x\in\mathcal{X}}{p(x)p(Y|T,x)}\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
20 (Confounder) \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(\sum_{x\in\mathcal{X}}{p(x)p(Y|T,x)}\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(\sum_{x\in\mathcal{X}}{p(x)p(Y|T,x)}\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(\sum_{x\in\mathcal{X}}{p(x)p(Y|T,x)}\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
21 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
22 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
Not Identifiable \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
23 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) \(p(Y|T,X)\) |
\(p(Y|T)\) Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y|T)\) Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
Not Identifiable Not Identifiable |
24 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(p(Y|X)\) |
25 \(p(Y(T))\) \(p(Y(T)|X(T))\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(\frac{p(Y)p(X|Y,T)}{\sum_{y\in\mathcal{Y}}{p(y)p(X|y,T)}}\) |
\(p(Y)\) \(\frac{p(Y)p(X|Y,T)}{\sum_{y\in\mathcal{Y}}{p(y)p(X|y,T)}}\) |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) \(\frac{p(Y)p(X|Y,T)}{\sum_{y\in\mathcal{Y}}{p(y)p(X|y,T)}}\) |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |
\(p(Y)\) Not Identifiable |